Army Physician Decision by the Physical Evaluation Board, Opening Path Toward Recovery and Renewal
The Law Offices of David P. Sheldon, PLLC is pleased to share that a client represented before a U.S. Army Physical Evaluation Board (PEB) has formally accepted the board’s findings, completing a significant step in their journey toward recovery and transition. The case is unique as DOD standards are much more stringent regarding Fitness for Duty when applied to physicians serving on active duty.
After months of evaluation, documentation, and review under the Department of Defense’s medical disability process, the client’s board findings were finalized, and the service member signed the formal DA Form 199, concluding the board’s deliberations. The acceptance signifies not only closure within the administrative process but also a personal milestone — a moment to focus on healing and moving forward.
“This stage often represents both an end and a beginning,” said Attorney David P. Sheldon, founder of the firm. “For many of our clients, the Medical Board/Physical Evaluation Board process can be overwhelming and deeply personal. Finalizing the findings allows them to reclaim stability and begin the next chapter with clarity and dignity.”
The MEB and subsequent Physical Evaluation Board (PEB) processes are designed to assess a service member’s fitness for continued military service and entitlement to disability benefits. For many, these proceedings determine the trajectory of their future — including retirement, benefits, and access to medical care.
In this case, the client’s acceptance of the board’s recommendations represents a successful navigation of a complex administrative system that ensures their medical conditions are recognized and appropriately rated. The outcome underscores the importance of due process, advocacy, and professional representation for service members facing health-related career decisions.
The decision came on the heels of the Informal Physical Evaluation Board finding the soldier Fit for Duty, which was appealed. At a formal hearing, presented by Mr. Sheldon, the Board reversed that finding based upon the testimony of forensic psychologist, another doctor and the Soldier as well. In closing, Sheldon did not mince words: “I understand the Army wants a doctor, they paid for a doctor, but through no fault of his own is this soldier fit to be a doctor.”
The Law Offices of David P. Sheldon, PLLC remains committed to supporting service members through every stage of the disability and separation process — from initial medical evaluations to appeals and correction of military records. The firm celebrates this client’s perseverance and courage in reaching this pivotal step toward long-term recovery and personal stability.
About the Law Offices of David P. Sheldon, PLLC
The Law Offices of David P. Sheldon, PLLC is a Washington, D.C.–based firm dedicated to defending the rights of service members, veterans, and federal employees worldwide. With decades of experience in military and federal administrative law, the firm represents clients before the Boards for Correction, Medical and Physical Evaluation Boards, the MSPB, and federal courts, ensuring that those who serve are treated with fairness, honor, and respect.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this post is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice or as forming an attorney–client relationship. The case details have been limited to preserve the privacy of the client and comply with applicable confidentiality regulations. Each service member’s situation is unique, and outcomes may vary based on individual facts, evidence, and applicable law. Readers should consult qualified counsel before relying on or applying the information contained herein.